|
see
the answers now!
Welcome to
this week's writing lesson from |
MyEnglishTeacher.net |
|
|
Who's Whose?
Lesson Topic: Possession, Contractions,
Apostrophes ('),
and Adding S
Look
at the following sentence and decide which word to use:
whose or who's
Who's
|
book is this? |
Whose
|
|
|
We won't tell you the
answer yet.
book
recommendation |
|
Action
Grammar: Fast, Easy Answers on Everyday Usage and
Punctuation
The author, Joanne
Feierman, focuses on the grammar most of us need in everyday life, from "Five Lies Your English Teacher Told You" to "Simple Business Verbs You Should Know." She also includes helpful sections on memos, letter writing, and e-mail etiquette, as well as an appendix of troublesome words and phrases, and words that are easy to misspell.
Click
here for more information. |
|
|
First, let us begin with
possession. If that book belongs to Marvin, we can say
When we are talking about possession,
we add an apostrophe and an s:
's
Marvin is a boy. Because Marvin is a
boy, we can also use the possessive adjective his. Therefore, we can write
The possessive adjectives are as
follows:
This is |
my |
book. |
your |
his |
her |
our |
their |
its |
|
Notice that NONE of these possession
words have 's. However, if the word is a name, you use
's. For
example,
This is
her book. |
This is
Joan's book. |
|
The word
Joan's has another meaning: it is a contraction for
Joan is. For example,
Joan is a
good girl. |
Joan's a good
girl. |
|
Therefore, 's can be used for
possession or contractions.
Now, here is the tricky part: for the
words who and
it, adding 's
has only one use—to show contractions.
no
apostrophe |
|
with
apostrophe |
Sam is
here. |
>>> |
Sam's
here. |
Who is
here? |
>>> |
Who's
here? |
It is
here. |
>>> |
It's
here. |
|
To show possession,
who and it
have other words (notice there are no apostrophes):
for who,
use whose |
>>> |
Whose book is on the table? |
for it,
use its |
>>> |
Its food is in the box. |
|
.
book
recommendation |
|
Barron's 1001 Pitfalls in
English Grammar English
grammar has lots of rules and exceptions to those rules. This book
nicely organizes all of those crazy rules and gives lots of examples.
This book is great for beginners through advanced levels
of grammar. The author answers lots of your toughest
grammar questions.
Click here for more information. |
|
|
So, now let's go back to the question
we first gave you at the top of this lesson:
Who's
|
book is this? |
Whose
|
|
|
Which word should we use? Since
who's means who is, ask yourself,
"Could I say the following sentence: Who is book is this?"
Of course, not. Is the question asking about possession?
Yes. Therefore, the answer is whose.
We can now update the list of
possessive adjectives from above. Whose
is a possessive adjective too.
LOOK! |
my |
your |
his |
her |
our |
their |
its |
whose |
|
Last, if a name ends in
s and you want to add
's to show possession, you can just add
just an apostrophe
(') or an apostrophe and s ('s). Both forms are correct. For example
CORRECT |
This is
Chris' school. |
CORRECT |
This is
Chris's school. |
|
Quiz
Directions:
Read the following sentences. Choose the correct word.
-
Who's/Whose
absent from school today?
-
I met a woman
who's/whose husband is a college
professor.
-
That's nothing! I met a woman
who's/whose the CEO of a billion-dollar corporation.
-
Her name is
Martha Stewart. Marthas/Martha's/Marthas'
home is in New York State.
-
Its/It's
a very large house who's/whose
landscape is absolutely exquisite.
-
The
Jones'/Jones's/Jones
new car is parked outside.
-
The car is
small, but its/it's
engine is a 300-horse-power motor.
-
I want to
know who's/whose
at the door.
-
Its/It's
the mailman.
-
Emily is a
girl who's/whose
my friend.
-
American
comedic team Abbot and Costello were famous for their skit "Who's/Whose
on First?"
-
A: I am the
boss!
B: Hmm. Who's/Whose
boss?
|
|
|
The answers
are in red.
-
Who's
absent from school today?
There is no possession here.
-
I met a woman
whose husband is a college
professor.
Whose represents woman; husband belongs to
the woman. The part of the sentence following
whose is an
adjective clause. For more information about adjective clauses with
whose,
click here.
-
That's nothing! I met a woman
who's the CEO of a billion-dollar corporation.
There is no possession here.
-
Her name is
Martha Stewart. Martha's home is
in New York State.
This is possession. The home belongs to Martha.
-
It's a very large house
whose landscape is absolutely exquisite.
It's is a contraction. Whose
represents house; the landscape belongs to the house. The part of
the sentence following whose
is an adjective clause. For more information
about adjective clauses with whose,
click here.
-
The
Jones'/Jones's
new car is parked outside.
Jones is a name which ends in s. This
is also possession. Therefore, both forms are correct.
-
The car is
small, but its engine is a 300-horse-power motor.
Its represents car; the engine belongs to the
car.
-
I want to
know who's at the door.
Who's is a contraction.
-
It's the mailman.
It's is a contraction.
-
Emily is a
girl who's my friend.
Who's is a contraction.
-
American
comedic team Abbot and Costello were famous for their skit "Who's/Whose
on First?"
Who's is a contraction.
-
A: I am the
boss!
B: Hmm. Who's/Whose
boss?
There is no absolute answer here. They could
both be answers. Why? Because person B may be asking
sarcastically and in disbelief "Who is boss?" On the other hand,
person B might be asking "You are the boss of whom?" Therefore, no
one knows the correct answer.
|
|
|
Rules to Remember!
|
1 |
The 's is used for both possession and contractions.
However, the words who and it have different forms for both possession and
contractions.
|
possession |
contraction |
who |
whose |
who's |
it |
its |
it's |
|
|
2 |
The words my, your, his, her, our,
their, its, and whose are all possessive
adjectives. None of these words have an apostrophe. |
3 |
Adjective
clauses can begin with both whose and who's. For more
information on adjective clauses with whose
click here. |
Do you want to send this lesson to someone? Click
here!
Want to see other lessons that have
been published on MyEnglishTeacher.net? Click
here!
Looking for books to improve your
writing? Click
here!
© 2002 MyEnglishTeacher.net. All rights
reserved. No information or lessons contained on this page or any page in
this Web site may be used without the expressed written permission of
MyEnglishTeacher.net and its parent company Advanced
Learning Center. This lesson may only be copied and may only be used
in a classroom for educational purposes exclusively. When using in a
classroom for educational purposes, this copyright notice MUST be included on
all copies. The material
contained on this page and all pages in this Web site are covered by copyright
laws. Therefore, no material may be used for
another Web site, book, magazine, or any other use. To use this material,
please email us at staff@myenglishteacher.net
©2000 Advanced
Learning Center. All rights reserved. If you find an error on
this Web site, please email
us and let us know. We appreciate all feedback and suggestions.
|